Published October 2002

Mutual funds vs. stocks: Which is ‘better’?

If you’ve been investing for a while, you’ve probably been exposed to both stocks and mutual funds. And, from time to time, you may have wondered which of these investment types is “better.’’ Does one offer more advantages than the other? If so, are you putting your money in the right place?

There’s no one “right’’ answer for everyone. In truth, both mutual funds and stocks offer distinct benefits. Here’s a quick look at some of them:

Advantages of mutual funds
n Diversification — When you buy a mutual fund, you automatically achieve a degree of diversification, because each individual fund may invest in dozens, or even hundreds, of different securities — stocks, bonds, government securities, money market accounts, etc. This diversification can help lessen the impact of downturns that affect one particular type of financial asset.

n Professional management — Mutual funds are run by professional “portfolio managers” who possess years of experience in analyzing the markets and selecting the mix of securities needed to achieve a fund’s particular goals (growth, growth and income, income, etc.). Of course, there’s no guarantee that your fund’s managers will live up to your expectations. Yet, there’s no denying the fact that, just by investing in a mutual fund, you are usually putting a great deal of expertise to work on your behalf.

n Affordability — It doesn’t take much money to invest in mutual funds. In fact, a person can set up a bank authorization to automatically invest as little as $25 per month in some funds. Thus, it’s easy to invest in a variety of mutual funds — which further diversifies an investment portfolio.

Advantages of stocks
n Potential for bigger gains — If you own an individual stock and it doubles in price, then you’ve made a 100 percent profit. But if your mutual fund owns that same stock, then the overall value of the fund may only increase slightly, if at all. However, the price of your single stock could also drop by half. If this same stock were in a mutual fund, the drop would not result in such a drastic decline in the fund’s net asset value.

n Lower investment costs — When you buy a mutual fund, you may have to pay a sales charge — also known as a “load’’ — along with operating expenses, which include management fees, 12b-1 fees and other expenses. Together, these charges can reduce your overall return. But when you buy a stock, you typically have to pay a one-time commission. (The same is true when you sell that stock.) Consequently, more of your money is working for you.

n Greater control over taxes — Mutual fund managers constantly buy and sell securities to boost the performance of their funds. Although you have no control over these trades, they may have tax consequences for you in the form of capital gains. When you buy a stock, you’re the one who decides when to sell it. Therefore, you’re in control of when taxes are paid on your gains.

As with any type of investment, stocks and mutual funds carry risks, including the potential loss of principal. It’s important to understand the risks as well as the potential rewards before you invest. Your investment professional can help you evaluate your situation and determine if mutual funds and stocks are suitable for you. Ultimately, you may find that a combination of both will help you meet your long-term goals.

Eric Cumley is an Investment Representative with Edward Jones Investments at 1201-C SE Everett Mall Way in Everett. He can be reached at 425-353-2322. Edward Jones is an NYSE-member investment firm with more than 7,000 locations nationwide.

Back to the top/October 2002 Main Menu