| HeraldNet - Snohomish County's online news source |
 THURSDAY, JULY 29, 2010 1:49 pm |
ADVERTISEMENT |
|||||||||
 |
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
Local News 
|
|||||||||
County to pay builders $1.7 million to settle suits The payouts settle lawsuits over decisions by the County Council and hearing examiner. Snohomish County has agreed to pay two groups of developers nearly $1.7 million to settle lawsuits over how the County Council and the hearing examiner handled land-use decisions.One case involved the County Council’s decision to sideline a pending request for a zoning change on land between Snohomish and Lake Stevens. That settlement gave $1.6 million to Bellevue development partnership SR9/US2 LLC. Separately, the county agreed to pay $90,000 to another developer, Lake Goodwin a Joint Venture LLC, over a decision by the county hearing examiner to order a formal environmental impact study for 600 homes that were proposed as nine separate subdivisions. With the settlement, the joint venture can now seek approval to build those homes on about 2,000 acres of rural land near the lake, which is northwest of Marysville. Despite legal rulings saying the county was wrong in both cases, the county’s decisions were based on common sense, Councilman Brian Sullivan said. “We really have to learn from our mistakes and tighten up the process,” Sullivan said. County codes should now be changed to better guide similar developments and protect against future lawsuits, he said. Both settlements stem from development requests that began in 2006, a year before Sullivan was elected to the council. The four other councilmen, three of whom were attending a conference in Washington, D.C., were not reached for comment. SR9/US2 LLC wanted to build houses and businesses on 140 acres northwest of U.S. 2 and Highway 9. The company asked the county to put the rural land in the city of Snohomish’s urban growth boundary to allow for the development. The city of Snohomish later joined forces with the developer, sparking a dispute with Lake Stevens over who should be allowed to annex the land. That fight continues. The company applied for the zoning change in 2006. In 2007, the County Council decided it needed an in-depth environmental review that would take more than a year. During the review process, the company says it paid $162,000 directly to the county’s planning department to prepare a supplemental environmental impact statement, plus $1 million on consultants, for a hearing that was to take place in 2009. In June 2008, the council voted to remove SR9/US2’s request from the hearing docket and labeled it “do not process further.” County officials said they had to turn down the request because population estimates showed no need for urban development in that area. The developer sued in King County Superior Court and in June of last year, a judge agreed the county treated the developer unfairly. The $1.6 million settlement was signed Feb. 4. Michael Reid, a co-manager of SR9/US2, declined to comment. The Lake Goodwin project is a joint venture between the McNaughton Group of Edmonds and Granite Land Co. of California. In 2006, the joint venture applied for the first of nine separate permits to build adjacent rural-cluster subdivisions on the land northwest of Marysville. Nearby residents opposed to the development formed a nonprofit group called 7-Lakes. The group’s founder said Wednesday she was upset by the settlement. “They rolled over and paid a developer for pushing through crap,” said Ellen Hiatt Watson, who ran for county council in 2009. “I believe that we still have a conservation opportunity and we’ll still be pursuing that.” Company officials say they plan to build the homes, though Watson said she doubted they would. The recent legal activity centers around one application for a 49-home subdivision. Dykes reasoned that the developer needed to consider the combined impact of all applications and the 600 houses that would be there after all the subdivisions were built. Last year, she ordered an environmental impact statement, a move that could delay construction by months and cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. In December, King County Superior Court judge Paris Kallas overruled hearing examiner Barbara Dykes, calling her order “arbitrary and capricious, and illegal.” The judge’s decision allowed the developer to file a separate damage suit. County attorneys asked the judge to reconsider, but were turned down. The $90,000 agreement came on Feb. 26. “We’re satisfied with the resolution,” said Brian Holtzclaw, the McNaughton Group’s general counsel. “We appreciated coming to a quick resolution.” Holtzclaw said the company intends to build the homes. The settlement was significantly lower than the $2 million McNaughton’s leadership initially said the company wanted. The county’s decision to settle the Lake Goodwin case was intended to minimize risk to taxpayers, said Michael Held, a Snohomish County senior deputy prosecuting attorney who handled the case. The county might have won an appeal, but also risked losing much more than $90,000. “Obviously, there’s no guarantee the county would prevail,” Held said. “We were confronted with the spectre of damages potentially in the millions of dollars.” Noah Haglund: 425-339-3465, nhaglund@heraldnet.com. |
- Mukilteo group fighting Eyman initiative remains a mystery
- Stuck climber gets a lift from ledge near Granite Falls
- Man killed in hit-and-run accident named
- Monroe may cut police, other city workers to make budget
- Neighbors respond after fire at park
- 1 dead, 2 injured in bear attack at Montana campground
- Three injured in Tulalip propane tank explosion
- This year's race could be Sen. Murray's toughest yet
- New BP chief; 2 new oil spills
- Dinner is served, with help of many
- Mukilteo group fighting Eyman initiative remains a mystery
(63) - Monroe may cut police, other city workers to make budget (22)
- Stuck climber gets a lift from ledge near Granite Falls (12)
- Arizona helped deport thousands without new law (8)
- Obama to campaign in Seattle for Sen. Murray (8)
- Everett spends thousands for
dog-waste bags (5)
- Everett takes another look at RV code after residents complain (5)
- Lynnwood cops face job cuts (5)
- Woman dies after being struck by truck in Mukilteo (5)
- County's internal report finds no proof of botched autopsies (4)
- 'Deadliest Catch' stars at MLT festival
- Edmonds post office to move
- Celebrating 30 years of playing ball
- Tour de Terrace whirlwind brimming
- Jackson graduate is taking steps to improve his swing
- Activities Calendar
- Braille students get a feel for wildlife
- Lynnwood cops face job cuts
- Cascade posts loss; FDIC acts, 2 directors quit
- Motor Trucks forges ahead with new Everett showroom
- Look for ‘lean' ways to bolster bottom line
- Stevens plus Swedish equals more care, closer to home
- Businesses can learn from Horatio Nelson’s life
- Voters should consider candidates’ business stance
- City Bank takeover is a boon to its buyer
|
|
 
|
|
|
|
| TODAY'S TOP JOBS |
| View All Top Jobs |
| Top Cars |
|
| Top Homes |
|
|
ADVERTISEMENT |
|
|
|Contact Us
|Advertiser Services
|Home Delivery
|Newsstand Locations
|Classifieds
|Feedback
|About the Company
|Work@the Herald
|Site Map |
|
COMMENTS | Be the first to comment
Log in or register to post a new comment.
To read other terms and conditions, click here